Search EconLog

Kidney Selling Coming Soon to Singapore!

Home
| EconLog
| Archives
| Permanent Link and Comments

The sweet voice of reason works swiftly in Singapore. Less than six months after I blogged about its Health Minister's interest in legalizing kidney sales, it's "almost certain to pass into law after another reading in Singapore's government-dominated parliament." The whole story:

A controversial amendment to legalize the payment of compensation to organ donors was put before the Singapore parliament this week and while the health ministry is yet to decide on the upper limit for reimbursement, it is expected to be at least S$50,000 (US$33,000).

Better still, it's kidney trading without anti-foreign bias:

Critics [Curse their evil minds! - BC] point out that while this sort of figure may be viewed as just compensation by a Singaporean professional who has to take months off work, the same amount would be an inducement to many less well-off people both within Singapore and from neighboring countries such as Malaysia and Indonesia. And, crucially, the government has insisted that it will not be bringing in a ban on foreign donors receiving compensation, which would be paid by the receiver or charities such as the National Kidney Foundation, as to do so would be discriminatory.

My question for Singaporean readers: If you put this measure up for a popular vote, would it pass?

HT: Tyler

Comments and Sharing

CATEGORIES: Cross-country Comparisons
Follow Bryan Caplan on Twitter

COMMENTS (4 to date)

Latest Comment

Anon writes:

Wow, that's even more beautiful than I thought.

The compensation is going to be far above the international market rate (in Iran and India), but that's a reasonable cost to weaken opposition, and it will give them more donors to select among to ensure quality.

I'm sure the Singaporean government has thought carefully about the implications for medical tourism, although I wonder if European and American health insurance companies will be permitted to pay for it, now or for very long.

Hopefully, they'll keep detailed records, and the surge in transplants will set off a domino effect among Asian countries (China is already taking organs from prisoners, it's not much of a leap to sale).

Posted January 22, 2009 12:08 PM

Jacob Miller writes:

Has an economist already calculated the projected number of lives saved for Singapore? I'm disappointed that this aspect wasn't mentioned in the article. People seem to obsess over the transaction and fail to mention the benefits for either party.

Posted January 22, 2009 2:00 PM

mgroves writes:

You know how liberals sometimes said "I'm leaving the US and moving to Canada/Europe if Bush is re-elected"? I think I shall substitute Singapore and Obama and make the same joke.

Posted January 22, 2009 10:59 PM

John Smith writes:

Singapore Reader. Yes. Will vote for it

Posted January 23, 2009 11:44 AM

Comments for this entry have been closed

Read comments

Return to top

Blogging software: Powered by Movable Type 4.2.1.
Pictures courtesy of the authors.
All opinions expressed on EconLog reflect those of the author or individual commenters, and do not necessarily represent the views or positions of the Library of Economics and Liberty (Econlib) website or its owner, Liberty Fund, Inc.

The cuneiform inscription in the Liberty Fund logo is the earliest-known written appearance of the word "freedom" (amagi), or "liberty." It is taken from a clay document written about 2300 B.C. in the Sumerian city-state of Lagash.

Contact Site Map Privacy and Legal http://www.econlib.org