Guilty as Charged

And because of this, we’d all be better off if you didn’t participate in economic decision-making.

I think Caplan would say we'd all be better off if you didn't participate in political decision making.

Your e-stalker is not only a jackass, but he's an appologist for Communism, it appears. Typical academic.

Also, he writes:

Often enough, people become wealthy through social privilege and blind luck. But Caplan ignores these realities

I am sick and tired of the left justifying theft on the basis that I obtained my property through luck. My wealth may have a component of luck to its acquisition, but that is no justification for it being taken away from me through taxation.

HAHA Brian

I must say that your comic photo was by far the most flattering. The rest of the conservatives profiled look less than amused in their pic. Although, the funny part about the whole "know your right winger" section is that if you were to engage any of those people in conversation they would probably hate your guts just as much as they hate the left. Michelle Malkin and Brian Caplan in the same political camp, now that is comical.

I'm jealous. Where's me? I know, I know, I 'm not yet famous, and I'm not really a Right-winger (that doesn't matter to the Left -- if yu are in favor of free markets, you are a Right-winger, even though the political Right is as anti-free markets as the Left; some people don't know the different between the political Right and classical liberalism), but still, it would be nice to be on someone's hate list! :-) P{erhaps one of these days. One cannot be a classical liberal academic and not find hatred thrown his way sooner or later.

It's unfortunate Mr. White sees democracy as an end to itself, and not a means to the goal of maximizing individual liberty.

Progressive critics of “free trade” don’t distrust foreigners. If anything, they simply distrust corporations that have long histories of exploiting foreign workers

Right, and putting up trade barriers or trying to force other countries to regulate their economies for trade deals, thus reducing their economic competitiveness and helping out American workers, isn't exploitative in any way.

I also like the implication that believing you are right and the majority is wrong is well, wrong.

At least Caplan is honest about his elitist tendencies. "In a modern democracy, not only can a libertarian be elitist; a libertarian has to be elitist," he wrote. "To be a libertarian in a modern democracy is to say that nearly 300 million Americans are wrong, and a handful of nay-sayers are right."

Yes? So? Couldn't one say this about any political belief system when it was in it was in the minority? Progressives had to believe they were right and millions of Americans were wrong when they started out. Same thing with abolitionists. And those elitist wingnuts in the Enlightenment who decided a republic was a better idea despite millions of people and centuries of history favoring monarchies.

Progressives should know better than to make such an argument. Claiming to know a better policy than the majority isn't necessarily wrong. After all, how many Americans really agree with the views espoused by campus progress. If the majority dissents, are the activists trying to promote change there elitists to be shunned?

I may not be in line with Caplan's views all the time, but that analysis certainly didn't convince me of the superiority of the far left either.

You're too charitable, Bryan. I thought it sucked.

He misrepresented key tenets and danced around hard nuggets. He's a lightweight. You're far too nice.

"But as liberal economist Jared Bernstein of the Economic Policy Institute recently wrote in The American Prospect, Caplan’s biggest problem is that "he fails to show that his version of economics gives us the optimal policies." His "anti-market bias" argument, for example, criticizes progressives for focusing too heavily on motives rather than results, but he obscures the often remarkable levels of corruption and greed guiding decisions that in fact don’t end with optimal results for society"

I don't see White calling Bernstein to task on proving the opposite nor does he ask himself about the greed and corruption of government.

Like I said, it sucked.

I'll second what Pertz said about your picture, it makes you look really cool. Are you sure he didn't mix up you image with Will Wilkinson?