Bryan Caplan  

How Did For a New Liberty Influence MRV?

PRINT
Power over Pay... I Take (Some of) It Back...
My co-author Scott Beaulier blogs a meaty question for me:
...The policy implication often taken from MRV is an elitist one: the world needs constraints from the mob through franchise restrictions, etc.  While Rothbardhad his elitist moments (and there's plenty in the Austrian oral tradition to support the Rothbard as elitist position, too), I've always thought of him as a "people's libertarian."  That is, we need a lot of "buy-in" from the mob before we can enjoy a new liberty.
In MRV, franchise restrictions only get a paragraph.  I spend more far time on the need for better economic education - and this probably reflects Rothbard's influence on me.  He certainly lives up to my three rules for improving economic communication: "(1) Highlight the contrast between the popular view and basic economics in stark terms; (2) Explain why the latter is true and the former is false; and (3) Make it fun." 

I completely agree with Rothbard that massive "buy-in" will be required
to really get a libertarian society.  Unlike Mr. Libertarian, however, I'm willing to bluntly admit that persuading the man-in-the-street is extremely difficult, and explore substitutes - however imperfect - for mass conversion.

The key difference between Rothbard and me, though, is that he refuses to acknowledge the hard fact that American elites, for all their statism, are much more libertarian than the general public.  He's according willing to embrace demagoguery, while I see this as not just morally wrong, but pointless.

Scott continues:
Do you think of your major project as one consistent with Rothbard?  Or, is this is a case of the two of you slaying different dragons (e.g, he's trying to popularize libertarianism; you're addressing a major issue in public choice--voter ignorance/irrationality)?  Given that it was such an influential book on you, I'm just wondering if Rothbard's influence is showing up at all in MRV?

MRV is inspired by my libertarian outlook.  It is to a large degree an attempt to rebut what I see as the most intellectually powerful critique of libertarian economics - Donald Wittman's The Myth of Democratic FailureUnlike Rothbard, though, I strive to be both scientifically and normatively persuasive to smart people with no libertarian sympathies.


Comments and Sharing


CATEGORIES: Book Club
Twitter: Bryan Caplan @bryan_caplan



COMMENTS (1 to date)
John writes:

If I may paraphase, this is one of the finest quotes I have read in some time.

" I strive to be both scientifically and normatively persuasive to smart people with no libertarian sympathies."

Comments for this entry have been closed
Return to top